Mohammad Kaif ne uthaye sawal Shubman Gill ke decision par. Karun Nair ko chhoda gaya must-win Manchester Test mein. Kya yeh Shubman aur Karun controversy ban chuki hai Team India ke liye?
Manchester Test ke liye Shubman Gill ka decision, jahan unhone Karun Nair ko drop karke Sai Sudharsan ko wapas team mein liya.
Ek naye controversy ka roop le chuka hai. “Shubman Gill aur Karun Nair controversy” ab fans aur experts ke beech ek garam topic ban gaya hai, jisme sabse zyada naraaz dikh rahe hain former cricketer Mohammad Kaif.
You may also read :- Bangladesh Fighter Jet Crash: Milestone School Tragedy Mein 27 Ki Maut, Fighter Plane F-7 BGI Ka Hua Bhayanak Accident
Mohammad Kaif ne uthaye sawal Shubman Gill par
Former Indian cricketer Mohammad Kaif ne openly criticize kiya Gill ke decision ko, jisme unhone Karun Nair jaise experienced batter ko crucial Manchester Test se bahar kar diya. Kaif ke mutabiq, yeh ek “izzat kamaane ka mauka” tha Gill ke liye, jahan wo ek struggling senior player ke saath khade ho sakte the. Par unhone yeh tough call lene ke bajaay Karun Nair ko chhod diya, jisse Kaif ne apni “respect” kho di Gill ke liye.
“Shubman Karun controversy” isi wajah se social media par trend kar rahi hai. Fans divided hain—kuch log team selection ke sath khade hain, toh kuch Karun Nair ke unfair treatment par naraz hain.
Karun Nair ka England Tour: Redemption ya Disappointment?
Karun Nair ke liye yeh England tour redemption ka ek mauka tha. 8 saal baad unhe Team India mein wapas jagah mili thi. Lekin unfortunate performance ke karan—sirf 131 runs in 6 innings at an average of 21.83—unka comeback weak raha.
Unhone ek bhi half-century nahi maari. Is wajah se team management ne unhe drop karke Sai Sudharsan ko wapas khilaya, jinhone pehla Test khela tha Leeds mein jahan unka score tha 0 aur 30.
Par Kaif ka maanna hai ki “last match” ek genuine chance ho sakta tha Karun ke liye, especially jab yeh venue pehle kabhi India jeeti nahi thi. Unhone kaha:
“Gill ke paas tha ek mauka team aur fans ke saamne ek strong leader banne ka. Par usne safe decision liya.”
Team India Strategy: Kya Sudharsan sahi choice the?
India ne Manchester Test ke liye teen bade changes kiye:
- Sai Sudharsan in place of Karun Nair
- Anshul Kamboj (debut) for injured Nitish Kumar Reddy
- Shardul Thakur for Akash Deep
Shubman aur Nair controversy ko aur fuel mila jab fans ne dekha ki Sudharsan pehle match mein bhi impactful nahi the, aur unko wapas team mein lana “preference politics” lag raha tha.
Par kuch experts maante hain ki Karun ki poor form ko dekhte hue decision practical tha. Team India ko must-win match mein ek fresh mindset chahiye tha.
Social Media Reaction: Fans divided on Shubman Gill Karun Nair Controversy
Twitter, Instagram aur cricket forums par fans ke reactions mixed rahe:
- Support Nair: “He deserved a proper goodbye match. What was the point of calling him back after 8 years?”
- Support Gill: “It’s about the team, not emotions. Karun was not performing.”
Ek aur viral comment tha:
“Shubman ne team ke captain hone ke sense mein nahi, ek management puppet jaise decision liya.”
Kya Gill ka decision leadership test tha?
Manchester Test ek aisa mauka tha jahan Gill apni captaincy ki maturity dikhate, lekin unhone ek “safe bet” choose ki. Shubman aur Karun controversy is baat ko highlight karti hai ki Indian team ka selection sirf performance par nahi, politics aur perception par bhi chalta hai.
Agar India yeh match haar jaati hai, toh yeh decision Gill ke upar aur pressure laayega. Aur agar jeet jaati hai, toh controversy thodi thami zarur jaayegi, lekin Karun Nair ke career par sawal hamesha ke liye chhap gaye hain.
Conclusion: Kya Nair ke saath nainsaafi hui?
“Gill Karun Nair controversy” ne Indian cricket mein ek nayi debate shuru kar di hai:
Kya senior players ko ek aur mauka milna chahiye, ya sirf form ke basis par selection hona chahiye?
Mohammad Kaif jaise players ka openly Gill par aana yeh dikhata hai ki dressing room aur management ke decisions par transparency ki zarurat hai.
Team India ke future aur Gill ki captaincy dono hi is controversy ke long-term impact ka samna karenge.